{ "scope": "Isolated native Unity editor E738 admission comparison; identical complete pipeline and helpers except the minimum managed element-size predicate. Not a player or native C++ claim.", "environment": { "unityVersion": "6000.4.6f1", "runtimeVersion": "4.0.30319.42000", "operatingSystem": "Windows 11 (10.0.26200)", "processorType": "Intel(R) Core(TM) Ultra 9 285K", "processorCount": 24, "pointerBytes": 8, "debuggerAttached": false, "profilerEnabled": false, "debugBuild": true, "stopwatchHighResolution": true, "stopwatchFrequency": 10000000, "probeDebugSymbols": false }, "sequencePerBatch": "ABBABAABCD", "sampleColumns": ["batch", "sequencePosition", "elapsedStopwatchTicks"], "arms": { "A": "Faithful upstream E738 minimum32-byte dense-disorder index route", "B": "Same full pipeline with minimum int.MaxValue, disabling E738 for tested40-byte records", "C": "Array.Sort same key-only comparer", "D": "IpnSort same key-only comparer" }, "bootstrap": { "draws": 2000, "seed": 747, "unit": "Paired complete eight-slot A/B batch;8batches sampled with replacement", "statistic": "median B / median A", "intervalPercentiles": [2.5, 97.5] }, "change": "32 <= Unsafe.SizeOf() replaced by int.MaxValue <= Unsafe.SizeOf(); no other pipeline, route, classifier, or merge change.", "validation": "Historical wide replicas checked sorted expected keys, uniqueness after narrowing identity to Int32, and fields3,4,5. The timing data does not independently establish full64-bit identity range or original key-to-tuple association; the real NUnit regressions establish complete value/permutation behavior separately. All32A/32B paired samples and8C/8D controls retained per cell.", "decision": "The compact-index route regresses both40-byte shapes under both interface/reference and concrete struct comparers. This supports a documented C# backend adaptation omitting the E738 route rather than assuming the C++sizeof32 gate transfers to managed generic comparers; larger payload crossover is not established.", "cases": [ { "comparer": "Interface containing reference comparer", "shape": "AlternatingDuplicates", "count": 100000, "elementBytes": 40, "backing": "Array", "assemblyName": "PipelineRunScript_JesseIndexVsNoIndexInterface_d6b2a9d84cf44529b19a65f5af04b0d0", "sourceSha256Lf": { "A": "776a9848df3da2e0600c1b676d1bd85ac38b5066a1c7ba0a46b13741a2fdac47", "B": "342b5909fcbdc17fca0cefeb008a50ce8657b80083153b3d066a622ecde476b7" }, "harnessTemplateSha256": "61d5c5d6e8851c8b5992bcead1d3e5c8bca6db5c3382848028396312769cee8c", "repetitions": 9, "minimumSlotMs": 41.7122, "emptyLoopTicks": 247, "medianMs": { "A": 11.38546111111111, "B": 5.204022222222223, "C": 8.21345, "D": 5.492183333333333 }, "quartilesMs": { "A": [10.888227777777779, 12.360569444444444], "B": [4.957708333333334, 5.536397222222222], "C": [7.939777777777778, 8.38038888888889], "D": [4.885816666666667, 5.643055555555556] }, "noIndexToIndexMedianRatio": 0.457076105344877, "pairedBootstrapRatio95PercentInterval": [0.418273581343628, 0.47923402815429855], "samples": [ [0, 0, 1227786], [0, 1, 464101], [0, 2, 425911], [0, 3, 1047553], [0, 4, 464164], [0, 5, 1003298], [0, 6, 1153108], [0, 7, 490782], [0, 8, 760439], [0, 9, 539117], [1, 0, 1158584], [1, 1, 459887], [1, 2, 459251], [1, 3, 1267482], [1, 4, 506209], [1, 5, 1163442], [1, 6, 1132774], [1, 7, 496721], [1, 8, 776477], [1, 9, 435528], [2, 0, 905941], [2, 1, 444403], [2, 2, 439911], [2, 3, 1001467], [2, 4, 427319], [2, 5, 950814], [2, 6, 923108], [2, 7, 438188], [2, 8, 736194], [2, 9, 495492], [3, 0, 1081566], [3, 1, 519017], [3, 2, 761513], [3, 3, 1214624], [3, 4, 446441], [3, 5, 921355], [3, 6, 927965], [3, 7, 417122], [3, 8, 716900], [3, 9, 441122], [4, 0, 996497], [4, 1, 480187], [4, 2, 505479], [4, 3, 1017305], [4, 4, 455463], [4, 5, 1109712], [4, 6, 1120669], [4, 7, 526720], [4, 8, 701719], [4, 9, 493101], [5, 0, 986479], [5, 1, 445452], [5, 2, 474275], [5, 3, 950184], [5, 4, 450840], [5, 5, 1099652], [5, 6, 952692], [5, 7, 422514], [5, 8, 742227], [5, 9, 522152], [6, 0, 960325], [6, 1, 521885], [6, 2, 488701], [6, 3, 1010716], [6, 4, 494497], [6, 5, 1025204], [6, 6, 1048089], [6, 7, 488552], [6, 8, 752167], [6, 9, 503116], [7, 0, 1076648], [7, 1, 513245], [7, 2, 472560], [7, 3, 1024179], [7, 4, 502940], [7, 5, 1107139], [7, 6, 991098], [7, 7, 448849], [7, 8, 707620], [7, 9, 424084] ] }, { "comparer": "Interface containing reference comparer", "shape": "Random", "count": 100000, "elementBytes": 40, "backing": "Array", "assemblyName": "PipelineRunScript_JesseIndexVsNoIndexInterface_453fbcf01430497282357f5bad7ecf4f", "sourceSha256Lf": { "A": "776a9848df3da2e0600c1b676d1bd85ac38b5066a1c7ba0a46b13741a2fdac47", "B": "342b5909fcbdc17fca0cefeb008a50ce8657b80083153b3d066a622ecde476b7" }, "harnessTemplateSha256": "61d5c5d6e8851c8b5992bcead1d3e5c8bca6db5c3382848028396312769cee8c", "repetitions": 5, "minimumSlotMs": 49.0753, "emptyLoopTicks": 193, "medianMs": { "A": 24.87388, "B": 11.896460000000001, "C": 11.47523, "D": 12.23312 }, "quartilesMs": { "A": [21.78136, 27.046305], "B": [11.46144, 13.009900000000002], "C": [10.05552, 12.221725000000001], "D": [11.540455000000001, 13.72863] }, "noIndexToIndexMedianRatio": 0.4782711824612807, "pairedBootstrapRatio95PercentInterval": [0.4583759415878398, 0.5413147381514957], "samples": [ [0, 0, 1052711], [0, 1, 554820], [0, 2, 553835], [0, 3, 1087106], [0, 4, 533655], [0, 5, 1066403], [0, 6, 993920], [0, 7, 543244], [0, 8, 503456], [0, 9, 587579], [1, 0, 1031065], [1, 1, 547668], [1, 2, 536131], [1, 3, 1055800], [1, 4, 573688], [1, 5, 1066241], [1, 6, 1072872], [1, 7, 588222], [1, 8, 490753], [1, 9, 523949], [2, 0, 1149541], [2, 1, 572922], [2, 2, 568272], [2, 3, 1103391], [2, 4, 592184], [2, 5, 1095417], [2, 6, 1227674], [2, 7, 585934], [2, 8, 500736], [2, 9, 630646], [3, 0, 1372599], [3, 1, 641825], [3, 2, 647472], [3, 3, 1378102], [3, 4, 1694839], [3, 5, 1356021], [3, 6, 1259714], [3, 7, 593182], [3, 8, 681410], [3, 9, 695270], [4, 0, 1099296], [4, 1, 675629], [4, 2, 596464], [4, 3, 1114734], [4, 4, 676325], [4, 5, 1377205], [4, 6, 1552826], [4, 7, 718787], [4, 8, 587600], [4, 9, 688179], [5, 0, 1435467], [5, 1, 726641], [5, 2, 695495], [5, 3, 1351080], [5, 4, 642830], [5, 5, 1261844], [5, 6, 1323291], [5, 7, 659564], [5, 8, 668777], [5, 9, 685849], [6, 0, 1574909], [6, 1, 590010], [6, 2, 582412], [6, 3, 1089722], [6, 4, 573122], [6, 5, 1303142], [6, 6, 1297675], [6, 7, 626090], [6, 8, 559923], [6, 9, 545354], [7, 0, 1123505], [7, 1, 614720], [7, 2, 616754], [7, 3, 1336309], [7, 4, 635818], [7, 5, 1338137], [7, 6, 1380494], [7, 7, 673083], [7, 8, 591856], [7, 9, 592666] ] }, { "comparer": "Concrete readonly struct", "shape": "AlternatingDuplicates", "count": 100000, "elementBytes": 40, "backing": "Array", "assemblyName": "PipelineRunScript_JesseIndexVsNoIndexStruct_6f9f1047dea044c785ed9e7cd4e212ae", "sourceSha256Lf": { "A": "776a9848df3da2e0600c1b676d1bd85ac38b5066a1c7ba0a46b13741a2fdac47", "B": "342b5909fcbdc17fca0cefeb008a50ce8657b80083153b3d066a622ecde476b7" }, "harnessTemplateSha256": "fb0cda40e4ae2bf829411e16283ba09fa721c206d9214fc55a9e9611f0d258be", "repetitions": 8, "minimumSlotMs": 36.8711, "emptyLoopTicks": 194, "medianMs": { "A": 11.51655625, "B": 5.12169375, "C": 7.9831812499999995, "D": 5.638275 }, "quartilesMs": { "A": [10.740853125, 12.079459375], "B": [4.913475, 5.383265625], "C": [7.68941875, 8.227675000000001], "D": [5.526909375000001, 5.784003125] }, "noIndexToIndexMedianRatio": 0.44472441577316135, "pairedBootstrapRatio95PercentInterval": [0.428797433074227, 0.4650732094102478], "samples": [ [0, 0, 902046], [0, 1, 414097], [0, 2, 457103], [0, 3, 831775], [0, 4, 488043], [0, 5, 1185857], [0, 6, 1043315], [0, 7, 419227], [0, 8, 616133], [0, 9, 371752], [1, 0, 861786], [1, 1, 392449], [1, 2, 403853], [1, 3, 953443], [1, 4, 402028], [1, 5, 941827], [1, 6, 807380], [1, 7, 411556], [1, 8, 629892], [1, 9, 447839], [2, 0, 952273], [2, 1, 428983], [2, 2, 407915], [2, 3, 903287], [2, 4, 446771], [2, 5, 990332], [2, 6, 949237], [2, 7, 402892], [2, 8, 663935], [2, 9, 449164], [3, 0, 1099383], [3, 1, 794804], [3, 2, 368711], [3, 3, 731850], [3, 4, 435696], [3, 5, 761167], [3, 6, 843759], [3, 7, 403580], [3, 8, 595968], [3, 9, 714815], [4, 0, 747641], [4, 1, 392892], [4, 2, 414263], [4, 3, 956791], [4, 4, 445606], [4, 5, 890391], [4, 6, 876137], [4, 7, 390919], [4, 8, 656307], [4, 9, 475372], [5, 0, 950580], [5, 1, 376112], [5, 2, 413963], [5, 3, 959282], [5, 4, 447833], [5, 5, 834907], [5, 6, 882824], [5, 7, 403664], [5, 8, 612215], [5, 9, 425094], [6, 0, 855897], [6, 1, 393140], [6, 2, 387052], [6, 3, 1139807], [6, 4, 398705], [6, 5, 860392], [6, 6, 896190], [6, 7, 381807], [6, 8, 688037], [6, 9, 458503], [7, 0, 939362], [7, 1, 424768], [7, 2, 422294], [7, 3, 1090927], [7, 4, 391546], [7, 5, 1114231], [7, 6, 987581], [7, 7, 449417], [7, 8, 647417], [7, 9, 452960] ] }, { "comparer": "Concrete readonly struct", "shape": "Random", "count": 100000, "elementBytes": 40, "backing": "Array", "assemblyName": "PipelineRunScript_JesseIndexVsNoIndexStruct_a2d4e47b423b492ba17f972b96c91e66", "sourceSha256Lf": { "A": "776a9848df3da2e0600c1b676d1bd85ac38b5066a1c7ba0a46b13741a2fdac47", "B": "342b5909fcbdc17fca0cefeb008a50ce8657b80083153b3d066a622ecde476b7" }, "harnessTemplateSha256": "fb0cda40e4ae2bf829411e16283ba09fa721c206d9214fc55a9e9611f0d258be", "repetitions": 4, "minimumSlotMs": 40.6873, "emptyLoopTicks": 204, "medianMs": { "A": 25.62745, "B": 13.4693875, "C": 12.0778125, "D": 13.3857625 }, "quartilesMs": { "A": [24.955737499999998, 27.6756625], "B": [12.53665, 14.29105], "C": [10.83796875, 12.711325], "D": [12.6110375, 13.93493125] }, "noIndexToIndexMedianRatio": 0.5255843831516597, "pairedBootstrapRatio95PercentInterval": [0.5008505923004198, 0.5386315109179752], "samples": [ [0, 0, 1011552], [0, 1, 472900], [0, 2, 501956], [0, 3, 1115614], [0, 4, 1419822], [0, 5, 949554], [0, 6, 1017441], [0, 7, 568162], [0, 8, 508431], [0, 9, 558118], [1, 0, 1100948], [1, 1, 543084], [1, 2, 511837], [1, 3, 981523], [1, 4, 491186], [1, 5, 1017382], [1, 6, 1018099], [1, 7, 472689], [1, 8, 420891], [1, 9, 481653], [2, 0, 1009253], [2, 1, 487657], [2, 2, 566330], [2, 3, 1168583], [2, 4, 573391], [2, 5, 1026368], [2, 6, 931342], [2, 7, 501595], [2, 8, 406873], [2, 9, 534028], [3, 0, 965137], [3, 1, 596508], [3, 2, 526818], [3, 3, 963309], [3, 4, 557441], [3, 5, 990638], [3, 6, 1104164], [3, 7, 454185], [3, 8, 457956], [3, 9, 504996], [4, 0, 1000760], [4, 1, 571059], [4, 2, 538063], [4, 3, 1061046], [4, 4, 501079], [4, 5, 990110], [4, 6, 1079296], [4, 7, 531293], [4, 8, 437728], [4, 9, 565204], [5, 0, 1021683], [5, 1, 582935], [5, 2, 539135], [5, 3, 1023828], [5, 4, 479682], [5, 5, 1464301], [5, 6, 1192503], [5, 7, 556913], [5, 8, 508519], [5, 9, 502778], [6, 0, 858037], [6, 1, 538416], [6, 2, 546159], [6, 3, 1078048], [6, 4, 499720], [6, 5, 1073394], [6, 6, 1171121], [6, 7, 597991], [6, 8, 513362], [6, 9, 557157], [7, 0, 1093197], [7, 1, 580603], [7, 2, 528187], [7, 3, 1168669], [7, 4, 603586], [7, 5, 1245988], [7, 6, 1329458], [7, 7, 578259], [7, 8, 508269], [7, 9, 536833] ] } ], "faithfulCandidateCommit": "4ec12c5d2512b52824a59d778d625fcba4304103", "reproduction": { "generator": "scripts/benchmarks~/generate-jesse-parity.py", "templates": [ "scripts/benchmarks~/JesseParityHarness.cs", "scripts/benchmarks~/JesseWideParityHarness.cs", "scripts/benchmarks~/WideRecordComparer.cs" ], "note": "The checked-in replay templates add license headers, formatting, and a separate nested-comparer source file. Historical wide controls used weaker validation as described in their record; replay uses complete tuple association checks. Template hashes identify the original measured templates, not the subsequently packaged replay files.", "listWriteBackLimitation": "The generated source clones use an identical indexer-loop WriteBack shim for List, rather than production IListBulk.cs Clear/AddRange replacement. List cells compare those clones and do not measure the exact production List backend; array cells do not use this shim." } }